Skip to content
Vol. 6 · No. 01Archive

Q&A · Vol. 6, No. 01

How Clinicians Support Better Patient Care Decisions

Summary

Better care decisions begin with understanding what matters most to each patient. This article shares expert insights on goals, concerns, recovery, results, and budget. Learn how clinicians turn those priorities into clear, personalized care plans.

Contributor
Doctors Magazine
Published
November 17, 2026

§ How this was made

The perspectives in this article were written by the named contributors and submitted through Connectively. Connectively's automated system selected them and used AI to write the headline, introduction, section headings, summary sections, and illustration, and to make minor edits for clarity. Articles are assembled and published automatically. Report errors to corrections@connectively.us. How we make our content

What the experts said

9 signed answers

  1. Ask What They Want to Do AgainAlan Silberberg
  2. Define Success at Three MonthsRobert Kevlin M.S. CCC-SLP
  3. Identify the Daily Change That Matters MostDr. Jitendra Mohan Jha DrNB
  4. Protect What Recovery Must Not DisruptAndrzej Kulesza
  5. Address Each Person’s Greatest FearJillian Foglesong Stabile MD, FAAFP, DABOM
  6. Match Plans to Goals and BudgetJwalant Patel
  7. Picture a Choice You Can EmbraceDr. Manisha Mehta
  8. Let Desired Results Shape Aesthetic ChoicesRocio Romero PA-C
  9. Rank Her Priorities Before You AdviseDr. Zaher Merhi MD

Ask What They Want to Do Again

Board Certified By The American Board Of Anesthesiology In Pain Medicine And Anesthesiology Greater Austin Pain Center, Austin, TX In pain medicine, there is very often more than one reasonable path. A patient with a herniated disc might be a candidate for physical therapy, an epidural steroid injection, or, if those fail, more advanced options down the line. Clinically, several of those can be defensible. The right one depends on the patient. The conversation habit that has helped me most is asking one question before I talk about any treatment: "What do you want to be able to do again?" Patients tell me they want to sleep through the night, get back to work, walk the dog, or pick up a grandchild. That answer reframes the whole discussion. Now we're not comparing procedures in the abstract; we're comparing which path is most likely to get them back to that specific thing, and at what cost in recovery time, risk, and commitment. From there, I lay the options out from most conservative to most involved, and I'm honest about what each one realistically offers, including how long relief tends to last and what happens if it doesn't work. Then I let the patient weigh in. Many of my patients have felt rushed or pushed in the past. When they help choose the plan, they trust it, and they're far more likely to follow through.

Define Success at Three Months

Before I recommend anything, I ask, "If this goes well, what would you be doing in three months that you can't do now?" It sounds simple, but the answers change my advice. Two people with the same diagnosis can want very different things. One wants to order food at a restaurant without anyone stepping in, and another wants to be understood on the phone with a grandchild. Those goals can point to different options, such as intensive voice treatment versus a communication-focused plan, or in-person versus telehealth sessions.

I then ask what has gotten in the way before, how much time and energy they realistically have, and who will be helping at home. Only after that do I lay out the options and say which one fits what they told me and why. When I repeat their own words back, people stop feeling sold to and start weighing the options like partners. It also protects against the common mistake of recommending what I find clinically interesting instead of what they need. The recommendation is still mine to make, but the direction comes from them.

Identify the Daily Change That Matters Most

When more than one treatment is medically appropriate, I believe the first step is understanding what the patient wants to achieve, not simply explaining which treatment is available. Two people with the same diagnosis may have very different concerns, and those differences can influence which approach is most suitable.

In gastroenterology, acid reflux is a common example. Depending on the clinical assessment, treatment may involve dietary adjustments, changes in daily habits, medication, or a combination of these approaches. One patient may be struggling with symptoms that interrupt sleep, while another may be concerned about taking medication for an extended period. Both concerns deserve attention, but they can lead to different treatment discussions.

One conversation habit I consider particularly useful is asking, "If we could improve just one thing about how this condition affects your everyday life, what would matter most to you?"

The answer helps establish a practical starting point. For someone whose reflux frequently disrupts sleep, I would focus the discussion on symptom control, appropriate treatment, and habits that may worsen nighttime reflux. For someone worried about prolonged medication use, I would explain why medication may or may not be needed, how long treatment might continue, and when reassessment would be appropriate. Before making a recommendation, I also explain the expected benefits, possible disadvantages, and limitations of each reasonable option. I then ask the patient to describe their understanding of the proposed plan. This often reveals unanswered questions that a routine consultation might miss.

The lesson is that shared decision-making requires more than offering patients a list of treatments. It means identifying medically sound choices, understanding the patient's priorities, and reaching a decision together. The right treatment is not simply one supported by medical evidence. It is an appropriate option that the patient understands, can realistically follow, and has helped choose.

Protect What Recovery Must Not Disrupt

AK

Andrzej KuleszaCo-Founder & Medical Director, Zeus Detox & Rehab

In addiction treatment there is rarely a single right answer. For someone who drinks heavily, outpatient therapy, an inpatient programme, medication to reduce cravings, or aiming for reduction rather than full abstinence can all be reasonable, depending on the person. If I lead with my recommendation, many patients simply agree in the room and quietly choose something else at home.

The habit that has helped most is asking one question before I offer any option: "What would you need to protect while you get better?" The answers vary enormously: a job they cannot lose, children they will not leave for a month, a marriage that is fragile, privacy from their employer. That single answer often decides which option is realistic far more than the clinical picture alone.

Only then do I set out the options and say which one I would recommend and why. Patients hear the recommendation differently once they know I have listened to what matters to them, and the plan we choose together is much more likely to be followed.

Safety is the one area where I do not offer a menu. If someone has a history of withdrawal seizures, stopping alcohol at home without medical supervision is not one of the reasonable options, and I say so clearly.

Address Each Person’s Greatest Fear

JF

Jillian Foglesong Stabile MD, FAAFP, DABOMPhysician and medical reviewer, Sipra

Before I recommend anything, I ask the patient what a good result would look like six months from now, in their own words. One person wants to lose weight; another wants to keep up with their kids, sleep better or take fewer medicines. Those answers point to different plans even when the diagnosis is the same. Then I lay out the reasonable options side by side, including waiting, with the trade-offs in plain terms: how often, what it costs, the common side effects and what happens if it does not work. The habit that matters most is one question: What worries you most about each of these? The answer usually shows me which option the patient will actually stick with, and that is often the right one.

Match Plans to Goals and Budget

JP

Jwalant PatelPA-C · MBA, MyFitMed

I start by asking patients to share what matters most to them and what concerns they have about the options. Then I explain the main trade-offs in plain language and check that we have addressed their priorities. In my practice, I help patients sort through their concerns and explain why some issues may need attention first, since related concerns can affect one another. A useful habit is to pause and ask, "What matters most to you as we make this decision?" That helps keep the recommendation focused on the patient's priorities. Since we have lot of services that insurance does not cover, I also ask patient about their budget and then customize their plan based on their goals. This helps them prioritize based on budget, goal and current health.

Picture a Choice You Can Embrace

1. In fertility care there is rarely one “correct” path. For a couple with low AMH, IUI, IVF with their own eggs and donor-egg IVF can all be reasonable. What differs is what each option asks of them in time, money, physical strain and emotional hope. So I lay the options side by side in plain language: realistic success rates for their profile rather than headline figures, the number of attempts each usually takes, the cost, and what happens if it doesn’t work. Then I step back and let them weigh it.

The habit that has helped me most is to ask one question before I recommend anything: “If we look back a year from now, what would make you feel this was the right decision, whatever the outcome?” Some couples say “knowing we tried with our own eggs.” Others say “not losing another year.” That one answer tells me more about their priorities than any test report, and my recommendation is shaped around it.

Let Desired Results Shape Aesthetic Choices

RR

Rocio Romero PA-CPractice Director, ROW 89

In aesthetic medicine there is rarely one correct answer. The same concern can often be approached with an injectable, a device, skin care, or by doing nothing, and each of those can be reasonable. So I do not start with the options. I start with one question: "If this goes well, what is different for you three months from now?" Then I stop talking and let the patient finish.

The answer tells me what the decision is really about. Some people want a change others will notice, some want one nobody will notice. Some have an event date. Some care most about downtime, budget, or not needing upkeep. Two people with the same face can need different plans for those reasons.

Only after that do I lay out two or three options side by side in the same order every time: what it does, what it does not do, how long it lasts, what recovery looks like, what can go wrong, and what happens if we wait. I say which one I would lean toward and why, and I say clearly that waiting is an acceptable choice. For anything elective, I would rather a patient leave with a plan they understand than a treatment they agreed to because I sounded sure.

Rank Her Priorities Before You Advise

DZ

Dr. Zaher Merhi MDFounder & Medical Director, Velva Sexual Longevity

Before I recommend anything, I ask one question: what would you like to be different six months from now? The answers vary more than people expect. One woman wants sex to stop hurting. Another has no pain at all and wants her desire back. A third mostly wants to stop getting urinary infections. Those point to different treatments, even when the exam findings look similar.

For vaginal dryness and painful sex there are often several reasonable options: local estrogen, vaginal PRP, red light therapy, or a combination. They differ in cost, in time commitment and in how much evidence stands behind them. Vaginal PRP, for example, has one good randomized trial behind it, but it is still a single trial of modest size. I say that out loud. Women make better decisions when they hear the limits along with the benefits.

The habit that helps most is letting her rank what matters before I talk. If cost is her biggest concern, I start with the least expensive option that is likely to work. If she is a breast cancer survivor on an aromatase inhibitor, systemic hormones are usually off the table, and that narrows the list right away. Once her priorities are clear, the recommendation is usually obvious to both of us.